#188455gingerninja 666Tue, 8th May '12 2:04:20 PMfrom Aboard The Damocles
You people don't complain about Kkat changing the world of Equestria completely since it was well writeen, yet you object to the few (imo) plausible and possiblle changes that Somber makes
"Contests fought between two masters are decided instantly. An invisible battle is now raging between the two of them." Lulu vs Schneizel
#188456SwasfewsTue, 8th May '12 2:04:42 PMfrom New York
Aren't you the same people who were saying it was wrong for someone to give up on something before trying it? I mean, if Ginger hasn't given up on it, it can't be that off.
#188457storyyellerTue, 8th May '12 2:05:22 PMfrom Appleloosa
yet you object to the few (imo) plausible and possiblle changes that Somber makes
How is retconning the entire government a small, plausible change?
If there is anything that you are alone in thinking, it's "thinking that you're alone in thinking of your theories".
#188458SeraphemTue, 8th May '12 2:08:01 PMfrom Delamare
becuase Kkat didn't straight up retcon anything, she added to it, the changes were made over time after the show, not "oh wait this is how it REALLY was the whole time"
Build a fool proof system, and the world will create a better fool.
#188459SeregTue, 8th May '12 2:09:25 PMfrom South Africa
I don't like the sound of it, but I'll still try it (I'm going to imagine that most things Goldenblood did are just mind control though).
As for Hoofington, it wasn't mentioned in Fallout Equestria, but it was mentioned by Trixie in Boast Busters.
Unity of the Sun Mare
#188460SeraphemTue, 8th May '12 2:17:14 PMfrom Delamare
yeah i'm going with the dude is just lying his flank off.
Build a fool proof system, and the world will create a better fool.
#188461Death CloudTue, 8th May '12 2:17:27 PMfrom Horsehead Nebula
Before reading PH I didn't wanted to read from similar reasons. But it's not that bad. Somber is respectful for KK fic. Goldenblood is annoying but you can ignore him. Most changes aren't that big and Somber fixed issues with Stables or rainder virus. Stable 90 is screw up of Stable Tec, Scoot and rest of CMC had no idea of state of that Stable, and it's probably sabotage by somepony who wanted kill possible target of fic MacGuffinI Hoof was mentioned somewhere it that fic, but no much details
edited 8th May '12 2:18:57 PM by DeathCloud
Because he know I'm going to go out in this plane and I'm going to remove one of His creations from His universe.
#188462SeraphemTue, 8th May '12 2:18:45 PMfrom Delamare
and the whole raider virus, ugh much prefered Lil'pip's conclusion on raiders, they are just ponies that have been driven so far past the DEH that they snap.
Build a fool proof system, and the world will create a better fool.
#188463Japanese TeethTue, 8th May '12 2:18:53 PMfrom Meinong's jungle
@Ginger: From what it sounds like, the issues is that the PH author is basically retconning the canon to make his own characters cooler. Even FE didn't retcon canon so much as make it an AU. It would be like if Fallout Equestria revealed that Celestia, Luna, Discord, and Nightmare moon were all just puppets of an OC.
#188472Miss CheerileeTue, 8th May '12 2:29:02 PMfrom Ponyville
Oh, just realized. I didn’t end up watching Episode 5 and 6 either. Maybe I should do that...
#188473SeraphemTue, 8th May '12 2:29:59 PMfrom Delamare
no, Gilda still is guilty of the one great unforgivable sin.
Build a fool proof system, and the world will create a better fool.
#188474storyyellerTue, 8th May '12 2:30:32 PMfrom Appleloosa
I just ran a search on the PDF version, and Hoofington is mentioned six times. The first time is a newspaper article about a dragon attack on Hoofington. Then in a memory orb, the dissenter pegasi complain about it. It's mentioned by the Applejack Rangers when discussing options to transport Cottage Cheese, and it's mentioned in DJ-Pon3's broadcast about resistance to the Enclave.
If there is anything that you are alone in thinking, it's "thinking that you're alone in thinking of your theories".
#188475BluespadeTue, 8th May '12 2:31:11 PMfrom Texas
....somehow I have never noticed in all this time how crazy the ponyville houses look. One of them is shaped like a jester hat, complete with little bells hanging off. Who do ya think lives there?