My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Forum Archive (nuked Western Animation thread)
Page 13615 | Posts 340351 - 340375
Perpetual Lurker avatar
#340351
@JT The thing is, though, that Celestia obviously didn't become an Alicorn in the same manner that Twilight did, since the spell Twilight cast to do so had never been performed before. Combined with the apparent disappearance of the Element of Magic, who knows what exactly happened to her body.

edited 16th Feb '13 7:01:53 PM by PerpetualLurker

Fluid avatar
#340352 from The Netherlands
She ascended without previously knowing anything about it, and afterwards she tasked Star Swirl with figuring out how exactly this works. He only managed to get halfway.
storyyeller avatar
#340353 from Appleloosa
My favorite gag was when Pinkie took a drink for the purpose of doing a Spit Take. It added some levity to an otherwise ridiculously dramatic moment.

That was also one of my favorite moments. It's a shame they didn't have more funny moments to break it up.
Life is simple: it has no nontrivial normal subgroups.
Jakes Brain avatar
#340354 from Middle of Effing Nowhere
@Syd: I think it must have been Nicole's voice — I remember seeing Meghan McCarthy (or someone else in the know) complimenting her on Twitter earlier this week for her performance.
If your fanon leads to unfortunate implications that could not possibly be canon truth in the context of the show, your fanon is wrong.
Seraphem avatar
#340355 from Delamare
Well, and home, glad to see overall peopleliked the episode, and hopefully can quit bitching about Twilacorn.

And yeah we are now in a no pony zon...wait no we are not.

Seriouly looking forward to the next few months, just to see what fan content comes out, plus the comics, the offical books, all the panels and Q&A's with the writers and staff at all the cons coming up. There will be plenty to do while we wait for season 4
My random thoughts FOE liveblog
storyyeller avatar
#340356 from Appleloosa
What was stupid about the plot? Everything made sense as far as I could tell.

Well she could have just kept casting the spell until everypony was back to normal by chance.
Life is simple: it has no nontrivial normal subgroups.
Calnos avatar
#340357 from Nowhere
Maybe Alicorns are normally born, rare as they be, and Twilight is the first to "ascend" to alicornhood?

...We're gonna be talking about this for months hoping Season 4 clears it up, aren't we?
You there! Check out my Youtube Channel! The power of Ponies compel you!
Seraphem avatar
#340358 from Delamare
.... yeah, no. No gaurentee that would EVER work.

[up]And yeah the way celestia phrased it, and the fact she is differnt from the other three, makes me think she is the first to BECOME and alicorn, rather then simply be one. Or at least become one of their own doing.

Still going with the Headcannon Luna and Celestia were ascended when they first found and joined with the Elements.

edited 16th Feb '13 7:14:15 PM by Seraphem

My random thoughts FOE liveblog
CDRW avatar
#340359
That's like trying to brute-force a six digit pin number.

edited 16th Feb '13 7:14:02 PM by CDRW

And now its raining flaming zombie pirahanas everywhere.
Japanese Teeth avatar
#340360 from Meinong's jungle
@Perpetual: That might be true, but at the same time there's precisely zero reason to assume that she ever died in any sense. Even if her body was deconstructed by magic, it wouldn't be death or she'd have "died" every time she teleports.
Reaction Image Repository/Tumblr
marston avatar
#340361 from America
The new episode was awesome! Twilicorn is ridiculously adorable, there were some great gags too {Lol at the animals trying to cook RD}, I loved all the songs and think that their huge improovements over the songs in the S3 premire, and Derpy finally made an appearence after being absent for so long too.waii

Now the only thing I can hope for is that the fanbase will calm down now that the episode has actually aired. The drama was really starting to annoy me.

edited 16th Feb '13 7:14:23 PM by marston

Irish Zombie avatar
#340362 from Texas
We've still got the movie. If it takes place after this episode, it might just clear up some of what we're discussing.

Even if her body was deconstructed by magic, it wouldn't be death or she'd have "died" every time she teleports.

It is precisely for this reason that if teleportation is ever invented, I will limit myself to more conventional means of transportation.

edited 16th Feb '13 7:15:39 PM by IrishZombie

Oh, no! They've all transformed into giant, Swedish, lederhosen-clad yodelers! Run!
Seraphem avatar
#340363 from Delamare
The movie has been confirmed to be the launch of the new IP, so nope.

Plus Megan said she considered this episode to be part 1 of a three part story. So the premeir of season 4 should be a two parter picking up with dealing with what happened.
My random thoughts FOE liveblog
Irish Zombie avatar
#340364 from Texas
[up]It's the launch of the new IP, yes, but I also thought the plot involved the girls travelling to the universe the spin-off takes place in.
Oh, no! They've all transformed into giant, Swedish, lederhosen-clad yodelers! Run!
storyyeller avatar
#340365 from Appleloosa
That's the major thing that bothered me. Even if it was boosted by the Elements, it was still a two-line spell that cost apparently no effort to cast and didn't even require Twilight to be wearing her Element (which every other effect, including petrification and purification, as well as the magic resistance the Elements grant, requires).

The weirdest part is that apparently you can make up new spells just by rhyming.

Just what are those ropes attached to?

The same thing that the guy swung on in The Blind Bandit from ATLA.

Not so.

Which game?
Life is simple: it has no nontrivial normal subgroups.
Perpetual Lurker avatar
#340366
I still can't stop wondering about what exactly happened to the Element of Magic. Is it physically a part of Twilight now? Has it reverted to the state it was in before the pilot, invisible and waiting for a new "spark" to awaken it? Is this whole thing just a stupid plot hole? I guess we'll find out next time the Elements become relevant.
Applelight Limited avatar
#340367 from Manehattan to Canterlot
Was that crown the same one as before?

And why have I got the feeling that Twi can now do the rainbow gun without the others, so long as they remain friends?
Tealove is best pony. Ask The Mane Six
Japanese Teeth avatar
#340368 from Meinong's jungle
The same gem that's in the element of Magic seems to be part of her princess crown, so it's possible that the element just vanished and re-manifested later.
Reaction Image Repository/Tumblr
Seraphem avatar
#340369 from Delamare
It was magiacally returned to the location of the other 5 when Twi returned.

Wait, were they wearing their elements when she came back?
My random thoughts FOE liveblog
Whatshisgame avatar
#340370
Something I haven't seen pointed out here yet: the mailpony in this episode is the same one who had glasses in "Putting Your Hoof Down".
Perpetual Lurker avatar
#340371
They were not wearing them when she returned (aside from an animation error with Fluttershy that vanished when she turned around).
Enlong avatar
#340372 from The Underground Facility
I'm pretty sure she was wearing the Big Crown Thingy during her coronation, wasn't she?
I have a message from another time...
Applelight Limited avatar
#340373 from Manehattan to Canterlot
She was, but was that the same thing?

Probably was. And I guess she'll have on her all the time now.
Tealove is best pony. Ask The Mane Six
Perpetual Lurker avatar
#340374
She was crowed with a similar looking tiara, but it was definitely not the same one.
darkabomination avatar
#340375 from the Deepwoods
Wait, something happened to the Element of Magic? Couldn't see it of course, but I assumed it reappeared with her newly made body.
"Welcome. You have entered the cranial vistas of psychogenesis. This is the place of no-time and no-space. Do not be afraid."