My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Forum Archive (nuked Western Animation thread)
Page 12633 | Posts 315801 - 315825
Perpetual Lurker avatar
#315801
With regards to there being no mention of other bearers, that's why I said it's unlikely. From my point of view, though, if Celestia had four friends just as close to her as the mane six are to each other, I get the feeling that she wouldn't want reminders of the fact that she outlived them all prominently displayed in her own throne room. It's not egomania, it's attempting to avoid the pain of their loss.
Applelight Limited avatar
#315802 from Manehattan to Canterlot
MY TABLETS ARRIVED!!!

And what are we talking about?
Tealove is best pony. Ask The Mane Six
Whatshisgame avatar
#315803
I don't know German, but I'm guessing something to do with really bad snowstorms.
Not exactly; I don't know German either, but here's the German magazine comic, here's an English fan translation, and here's a reading of that.
Kyler Thatch avatar
#315804
I wonder. What if you had the scenario where one pony has a crush on another but is too afraid to admit it. Would Cadence's magic give them a shot of Dutch courage?
There's no need to sharpen my pencils anymore. My pencils are sharp enough.
Even the dull ones will leave a mark.
crowlover avatar
#315805 from Name & Address Withheld
I don't know German, but I'm guessing something to do with really bad snowstorms.

It means "The Star of Winter Dreams."

EDIT: And Ninjask'd

edited 12th Dec '12 12:00:25 PM by crowlover

Enlong avatar
#315806 from The Magitek Holyland
I prefer to think of the 'Dark Powers' that she spoke of were more Force-like than simply her making some deal with some unlikely devil character. Nightmare Moon was simply Luna but with crazy evil eyes.

Not a deal with the devil, but more like she evoked a sort of magic that she really couldn't keep a handle on, or at least, not in her current mental state. It made her really powerful, but continued her slide into madness.
I have a message from another time...
Sereg avatar
#315807 from South Africa
I see Nightmare Moon as Luna under very specific circumstances. Unde which she is significantly more powerful. I don't even think that Luna is fully grown (she'll be Celestia's size when she is and she'll be much more powerful then).

On Cadance's spell, it strengthens and repairs existing love, but that's not all she can do. Now, I may strongly disagree with the power level of alicorns in The Pony POV Series but I did find a scene in it both amusing and heartwarming where a confused!filly!Cadance is being scolded by Celestia for being irresponsible with her powers and nearly accidently causing a palacewide orgy. Of course, in that series, Cadance only believed that she was the alicorn of love when it's actually a different alicorn who is the alicorn of love and Cadance is the alicorn of music, harmony and bonds.

EDIT:[up]Agreed.

edited 12th Dec '12 12:02:17 PM by Sereg

Unity of the Sun Mare
Kyler Thatch avatar
#315808
Huh. Well, at least I got the winter part right.
There's no need to sharpen my pencils anymore. My pencils are sharp enough.
Even the dull ones will leave a mark.
Sereg avatar
#315809 from South Africa
@Kyler Thatch: I can totally see Cadance as being able to help the pony you mentioned.

Anyway, my version of the other for bearers were raised as undead servants of Nightmare Moon and became the stars which aided NM's escape.
Unity of the Sun Mare
Perpetual Lurker avatar
#315810
Well, at the very least we can now definitely peg her domain as Love and possibly Hope with her connection to The Crystal Heart, since those are explicitly the emotions that power it.

edited 12th Dec '12 12:10:03 PM by PerpetualLurker

Purple Dalek avatar
#315811 from Betelgeuse
Anyway, my version of the other for bearers were raised as undead servants of Nightmare Moon and became the stars which aided NM's escape.

I've heard that theory before and it's never quite gelled with me.

I know we're talking about magical talking horses here, but for me it's too farfetched for a little pony to somehow transform into a colossal (like, hundreds of times bigger than a planet) ball of fire and gas.

Yeah, we're talking about magic here, but there's a limit.
"A toilet with the potentially dangerous arrangement of the seat being up" - Wikipedia
Kyler Thatch avatar
#315812
You seem to be implying that their stars are colossal balls of gas and fire. For all we know, they could just be glow-in-the-dark dots painted on the inside of a ginormous sphere.
There's no need to sharpen my pencils anymore. My pencils are sharp enough.
Even the dull ones will leave a mark.
Great God Pan avatar
#315813 from The Woods. Where else?
I've always liked the theory that Celestia was responsible for the stars aiding hr sister's escape.
Spooky.
Sereg avatar
#315814 from South Africa
@Perpetual Lurker: I agree that Cadance is the alicorn of love. Just giving some context for the scene.

@Purple Dalek: I don't believe that they became true stars. For a start, stars can't really converge on the moon. Just looked like stars from Earth. They were just glowing brightly.

EDIT: Note, that turning someone into a star using magic is something that isn't out of the power of some wizards.

[up][up]I do believe that most stars are completely normal stars in MLP. This is an exception though.

[up]I like that theory as well. I still think that Celestia planned that evn if they were Luna's minions.

edited 12th Dec '12 12:17:44 PM by Sereg

Unity of the Sun Mare
storyyeller avatar
#315815 from Appleloosa
Even then, it still has potential. We know what those things can do in the hands of void abominations, great commanders and archmages, against similarly powerful opponents, but we have no idea what'd they do in the hooves of Mr. average pegasus in the middle of Canterlot.

Trixe is an Archmage? I doubt it.
Life is simple: it has no nontrivial normal subgroups.
Meta Four avatar
#315816 from riding the wave
Perhaps "the stars will aid in her escape" had a double meaning. In addition to the literal stars that Twilight saw helping NMM escape, it was a reference to the Elements of Harmony helping Princess Luna return to her right mind.
That would be running a punchline into the ground.
Kyler Thatch avatar
#315817
Ooh, I like that interpretation.
There's no need to sharpen my pencils anymore. My pencils are sharp enough.
Even the dull ones will leave a mark.
Purple Dalek avatar
#315818 from Betelgeuse
@Pan Yeah, I like that one too. It makes Celestia a clever chessmaster.

@Sereg We're calling the pony's world "Earth" now?tongue We do need a name for their planet as a whole, come to think of it.
"A toilet with the potentially dangerous arrangement of the seat being up" - Wikipedia
Lopiny avatar
#315819 from somewhere
@Story I didn't mean the Alicorn amulet in particular, I meant everything else, seeing that you compared it to League of Legends stuff.

edited 12th Dec '12 12:19:30 PM by Lopiny

Oh, the thread? Don't worry, it's just dead.
Sereg avatar
#315820 from South Africa
ade an edit.

Also, the ponies call it Earth. We've known that since Hearth's Warming Eve. Still would be useful to be able to easily differentiate it from out planet.
Unity of the Sun Mare
Perpetual Lurker avatar
#315821
They don't call it Earth. Earth was one of the proposed names for the new Earth Pony land. "Earth" in the context of their world simply refers to the ground they walk on, not the planet as a whole.
Meta Four avatar
#315822 from riding the wave
@Pan Yeah, I like that one too. It makes Celestia a clever chessmaster.
Not just a chessmaster, but one who prepared a thousand years and put herself in danger, just to save her sister.
That would be running a punchline into the ground.
Purple Dalek avatar
#315823 from Betelgeuse
Also, the ponies call it Earth.

Well, that's a pretty big coincidence. It's like finding an alien civilisation that call their planet Belgium.
"A toilet with the potentially dangerous arrangement of the seat being up" - Wikipedia
Meta Four avatar
#315824 from riding the wave
Watch your language, bud! This is a civilized forum here.
That would be running a punchline into the ground.
Great God Pan avatar
#315825 from The Woods. Where else?
I think it's more our fault as humans. I mean, what moron would call their own homeworld 'Dirt'? [lol]
Spooky.