I can understand that. Incest/rape/pedophila/murder is kinda a hard thing to want to write about, let alone think about it, and I think that's another reason why No one has written a fix fic based off of SAM yet.

Do you think I would get lots of hate for trying to write one.

No, not at all! I explained why I think no one has written fix fic for SAM, but that doesn't mean that no one would like it or even hate on you for writeing it. In fact, I think it might help anyone who was traumitized by that awful fanfic! If you do write it though, is it too much to ask that you post it on fanfiction.net or fimfiction instead of just Eqestria daily? I have to use the wii for internet right now, and google docs doesn't work on the wii.

edited 5th Dec '11 9:30:19 PM by marston

I don't have a fanfiction account. I could post it on deviantart, though.

DA works too. Also, I'm not saying that you shouldn't post it on Equestria Daily, just that it isn't the only place you should put it on.

Also, IF you do write your fanfic, a link to it would be nice too.

edited 5th Dec '11 9:37:29 PM by marston

Well, good luck to you in trying to write that. Like marston said, post a link if you do. I'm actually putting ideas together for a fanfic, myself.

That was actually more disturbing than cupcakes itself. Because while Cupcakes obviously couldn't have happened in cannon, that ending can be read to imply Pinkie struggles with homicidal impulses on a daily basis and is overly bright and cheerful to compensate.

Or she just had a really bad nightmare.

A nightmare she enjoyed while she was having it?

Where did it say she enjoyed it?

Her demeanor throughout?

In dream, you mean? Because if she had to be comforted by it, I doubt she enjoyed it.

She could be appalled by enjoying it.

...that hardly means she has a psychopathic person hidden underneath.

I said that The alternate ending implied she had homicidal impulses not The alternate ending implies she's a psychopath.

Semantics. Word choice is irrelevant. And you said the fic CAN be read that way, not that it was written that way.

But they are two completely different things.

Whatever. I used the wrong word than.

That hardly means she has homicidal tendencies.

I just said the fic could be read that way, which could ruin it's potential as a Fix Fic.

That is all, not a big deal. Jeez.

I never said it was a big deal. Just that it was a highly unlikely read.

I ended up reading it that way.

^Wow, your seriously disturbed by that fanfic? I thought it was heartwarming and cute. And about pinkie having possible serial killer tendencies: We don't know what the dream is since it's up to interpretation, but it was originally suppose to be a alternate ending to cupcakes before the author relized that there were so many of those. The fact that she needed comforting and she avoided doing whatever she did in her nightmare means that there's no reason to be disturbed by that fic.

And like I said, what the nightmare is about is up to you to decide. For all we know, it could have been the ask pinkimena blog. Oh wait, that's not really helping is it? lol

edited 6th Dec '11 8:31:48 AM by marston

I just read the trope page for Sweet Apple Massacre, and I feel a little woozy.

I plan on reading it anyway, because that's the kind of person I am, but I don't think I'm going to like what I see...

It doesn't really look like it was written with "fetishization" in mind, anyway.

That's not entirely what I meant. I meant that I like scary/gross stuff, not necessarily that I'm turned on by it.