My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Forum Archive (nuked Yack Fest thread)
Page 1 | Posts 1 - 25
The Mighty Anonym avatar
#1
What, exactly, would make a show like this so popular? Hell, I love this show. BUT WHY?!
Where were you when I laid the earth’s foundation? Tell me, if you understand. Who marked off its dimensions? Surely you know! ~ GOD
Inverurie Jones avatar
#2 from North of the Wall.
Hmm. Quite.
Winter is Coming In Absentia Lucis, Tenebrae Vincunt
Urist McDorf avatar
#3 from Equestria
If you find out, let me know.
BACK IN BUSINESS, BABY!
The Mighty Anonym avatar
#4
[up]I hope I do find out; but until then: MYSTERY.
Where were you when I laid the earth’s foundation? Tell me, if you understand. Who marked off its dimensions? Surely you know! ~ GOD
Urist McDorf avatar
#5 from Equestria
I'm going to go ask 4chan.

Maybe one of the /b/tards will have some insight into the matter.

It's better than no plan, anyway.
BACK IN BUSINESS, BABY!
The Mighty Anonym avatar
#6
I'm curious as to what their reaction would be.

edited 22nd Feb '11 1:09:28 AM by TheMightyAnonym

Where were you when I laid the earth’s foundation? Tell me, if you understand. Who marked off its dimensions? Surely you know! ~ GOD
Vorpy avatar
#7 from from from from from from
It's the same reason why Robot Unicorn Attack is so popular.

Because people have no self control and will go after cute things as long as their is no sexual context behind it, which is what My Little Pony is.

Plus the one person who likes it keeps talking about it

edited 22nd Feb '11 1:10:20 AM by Vorpy

If the amount of rape that is acceptable to you is not zero, and you are not Pyramid Head, you need to seriously rethink your life.
Gelzo avatar
#8 from the vault
This show already has at least two other threads on TV Tropes. Three if you count IJBM 2.

Anyway, don't bother asking /b/. There's usually a pony thread on /co/.

Better yet, I'll give my take on it. People like variety and quality in art. People are willing to appreciate cutesy shit, but nine times out of ten the people who make cutesy shit don't bother to make it any good. My Little Pony: Fi M is a very rare example of a girly show that has some care put into it. Naturally, it gets more attention and sticks in your head more than a show of comparable quality.

Also, there's an irony in enjoying this kind of thing as an adult man that I find very amusing. I have a feeling that this sort of thing is behind some of it.

[up] Ha ha no.

edited 22nd Feb '11 1:20:39 AM by Gelzo

Ruining everything forever.
Urist McDorf avatar
#9 from Equestria
/b/ told me that "it's a nice escape from the fucked up reality that we live in."

They also provided me with this photo: [1]

I'll ask /co/, too.

EDIT: One more.

first and foremost, friendship is magic!

more specifically, the show is rather well-written with enjoyable and dynamic characters. the creator, Lauren Faust, is Craig Mccracken's wife. The two of them have been involved in powerpuff girls, Foster's home for imaginary friends... somepony help me out, i can't remember what else... Also, damn near every frame is exploitable!

and it's also kind of a plus that it pisses off so many newfags, though honestly these threads are by no means a trolling effort!

edited 22nd Feb '11 1:24:26 AM by UristMcDorf

BACK IN BUSINESS, BABY!
goodtimesfreegrog avatar
#10 from Darkmere
Wow, there's definitely no dedicated subforum for this kind of thing that this couldn't have been posted in, no sirree.
READ THIS COMIC. | Read along as I play through my games collection!
Vorpy avatar
#11 from from from from from from
I Lied.

ITS JUST SO FUCKING CUTE AND GENRE SAVVY !!!!

Which is why everyone is gay for the show.
If the amount of rape that is acceptable to you is not zero, and you are not Pyramid Head, you need to seriously rethink your life.
Urist McDorf avatar
#12 from Equestria
I actually couldn't find a pony thread on /co/, soo... maybe another day.

But now... Now, I have to watch My Little Pony. I never imagined it.
BACK IN BUSINESS, BABY!
Vorpy avatar
#13 from from from from from from
Also, due to relatable characters that are all different. ^^

Just look at the O Ps picture. You will FIND YOURSELF IN ONE OF THOSE PONIES. CHOOSE ONE AND LOVE IT FOREVER.

Just not too much.

edited 22nd Feb '11 1:32:50 AM by Vorpy

If the amount of rape that is acceptable to you is not zero, and you are not Pyramid Head, you need to seriously rethink your life.
Gelzo avatar
#14 from the vault
Gee I wonder who Vorpy can relate to.

edited 22nd Feb '11 1:34:59 AM by Gelzo

Ruining everything forever.
goodtimesfreegrog avatar
#15 from Darkmere
I also really like the art direction of this show, which only really highlights how unlikeable the "classic" pony character designs were. And I do like how this show isn't really centered around the ponies doing "typically girly" things, which is a really obvious pitfall for shows like this.

Also Fluttershy is mai pony waifu
READ THIS COMIC. | Read along as I play through my games collection!
Urist McDorf avatar
#16 from Equestria
@ Vorpy: You're really getting into this, aren't you?
BACK IN BUSINESS, BABY!
Vorpy avatar
#17 from from from from from from
It's either Pinkie Pie or Rarity, Gelzo. I'll cycle between them for now. :P

And YES I AM

edited 22nd Feb '11 1:34:38 AM by Vorpy

If the amount of rape that is acceptable to you is not zero, and you are not Pyramid Head, you need to seriously rethink your life.
Gelzo avatar
#18 from the vault
I really like how they handled the main character. It's not often you get the smart/sane/socially awkward one in a leading role.

Fuck yeah Twilight Sparkle, keep rocking that empiricism.

edited 22nd Feb '11 1:36:49 AM by Gelzo

Ruining everything forever.
goodtimesfreegrog avatar
#19 from Darkmere
I wouldn't really call Twilight Sparkle a "main character" even though she is a signifigant focus in this show, but it's a good vehicle to carry across the central moral of the show about making friends.

Also god damn it Tara Strong why are you in every goddamn cartoon these days.
READ THIS COMIC. | Read along as I play through my games collection!
Vorpy avatar
#20 from from from from from from
It's the Magenta stripe maaan.

Damn. I need to wait for others to scour this for memes. I don't know any yet.

> >

[up] Tara Strong is able to play a lot of voices, and is one of the only Voice actors we have for cutesy voices that can actually go on for hours with herself without busting her voice. Rivalling her is Cree Summer, but she has too much jive for some roles.

edited 22nd Feb '11 1:39:01 AM by Vorpy

If the amount of rape that is acceptable to you is not zero, and you are not Pyramid Head, you need to seriously rethink your life.
goodtimesfreegrog avatar
#21 from Darkmere
>memes

Well, there's always Derpy Hooves...

[up] True, but to me she's kinda becoming the female Jim Cummings in that for all her variety she still has that very characteristic voice that leads to the usual Hey, It's That Voice! moment in anything she's in.

edited 22nd Feb '11 1:41:05 AM by goodtimesfreegrog

READ THIS COMIC. | Read along as I play through my games collection!
Urist McDorf avatar
#22 from Equestria
Currently loading the first episode of My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic on Youtube.
BACK IN BUSINESS, BABY!
Vorpy avatar
#23 from from from from from from
I WUV DERPY HOOVES

Well, there is always Abbey Mc Bride if we want an engrish girl. But that's not her only voice. Hell, I know very few female voice actors beyond Tara Strong.

edited 22nd Feb '11 1:42:56 AM by Vorpy

If the amount of rape that is acceptable to you is not zero, and you are not Pyramid Head, you need to seriously rethink your life.
goodtimesfreegrog avatar
#24 from Darkmere
Also [episode 9 spoilers assuming you care] Flutterguy is the most hilarious thing in the universe.

[up] Kinda says something about just how prolific Tara is in the biz, don't you think?

edited 22nd Feb '11 1:44:09 AM by goodtimesfreegrog

READ THIS COMIC. | Read along as I play through my games collection!
Urist McDorf avatar
#25 from Equestria
Oh dear god, I hope that no body sees me watching this.
BACK IN BUSINESS, BABY!