Maybe Pinkie doesn't even realize it's supposed to be scary because she just interprets "scary" as "silly."

Although she was scared of Zecora...

Or she'll show up with the scariest costume of all.

edited 30th Sep '11 11:56:24 AM by Crowfall

It would be cool if ponies dress up as G1 villains.

x 10 It would be pretty funny if she did. Turns up as a frightenly realistic looking zombie that scares the horseapples outta everypony, only for her to reveal herself, laughing her haunches off.

Yeah, that works.

Costumes. Calling them:

Twilight: A ghost?

Applejack: Lone Star or generic sheriff. Or a big red apple.

Rainbow Dash: Generic WB uniform with goggles

Rarity: Something greek or egyptian looking? Rarity as cleopatria!

Pinkie: Devil, cupcake or corpse.

Fluttershy: BUNNY! (Better happen!)

edited 30th Sep '11 11:59:29 AM by Justanotherbrony

I bet before the episode is done, we will see someone dressed up as Discord.

I can imagine Fluttershy barricading herself inside her own house for the entirety of Nightmare Night.

I am starting to like canon luna

Yes...while dressed like a bunny.

edited 30th Sep '11 12:02:31 PM by Justanotherbrony

Yeah. Poor Fluttershy.

edited 30th Sep '11 12:03:25 PM by kyun

Meanwhile, Angel struts out of the house and attends a highly exclusive Nightmare Night party. For rabbits.

That, or someone uses a Discord-like decoration in a "haunted house"-type thing. After all, he'd be pretty hard to dress up as.

edited 30th Sep '11 12:10:19 PM by Enlong

She's dressed up for a reason COMPLETELY unrelated to Nightmare Night

edited 30th Sep '11 12:04:08 PM by gingerninja666

Trixie shows up with no costume. Because she's in costume as her usual outfit!

...and no one recognizes her.

edited 30th Sep '11 12:04:50 PM by kyun

Spike will dress as a vampire.

Trixie will show up in town dressed as herself, but pretending to be somepony else dressed as Trixie, in order to gauge the town's reaction to her. Cue disappointment when no pony recognizes her.

But we saw her with no costume at the end of Boast Busters, people still recognized her

edited 30th Sep '11 12:10:31 PM by gingerninja666

http://bri-chan.deviantart.com/art/my-little-gargoyle-260929522

MY MONEY! TAKE IT! PLEASE!

If Twilight dresses up as a vampire, there will be sooooooo many Twilight Saga jokes abound.

And he wouldn't even need to buy fake fangs!

Pffhaha. That's be hilarious.

edited 30th Sep '11 12:11:19 PM by Enlong

I can imagine the creators doing that as well

edited 30th Sep '11 12:12:50 PM by gingerninja666

Or better yet, Twilight dresses up as a vampire. Although that joke is almost too obvious. I kind of envision Twilight doing the generic gost costume that's just a bedsheet with holes in it, because she has no clue what she's doing. And the idea of Fluttershy wearing the scariest costume is awesome. Also, Steven Magnet must show up dressed as Discord.

EDIT: epic ninja'd.

Anyway, I really hope that the info about Luna is true. If it is, this episode will probably be amazing. I'm thinking that she's going to try to ham it up, sort of playing a scary character in a non-scary way. Or maybe she's just wearing that hood thing because she's hosting the event and the host is supposed to dress up creepy. And yeah, it's smart that she's going to Ponyville; they're the most likely to accept her.

edited 30th Sep '11 12:14:14 PM by JapaneseTeeth

-imagines Gargoyles theme set to adventure episode of MLP-

SHUT UP AND TAKE MY MONEY!!

x 6 That. Is. SSSWEEEEEEETTT!

Twivamp must happen. It must. It must! IT MUST!

edited 30th Sep '11 12:17:13 PM by Justanotherbrony

Maybe she's the host of the holiday party but she's completely covered in a cloak, and nopony can identify who the host is until the end of the episode.

Luna has this weird voice, I can't describe it, I'm trying to imagine how she'd sound trying to be scary or a Large Ham

It sounds ridiculous

*5 Twilight will TRY To dress up in a ghost costume where she cuts eyeholes out of a bedsheet, but will accidentally cut out too many eyeholes.

edited 30th Sep '11 12:17:15 PM by SpaceJawa