Let's just agree to disagree, Ginger.

New topic: invent some silly fake gossip for the Cutie Mark Crusaders Paparazzi to discover bonus points if you guess an actual thing happening on Saturday.

Applejack eating a pear.

@Red My irritation is at the writers, and how they write Pinkie compared to everyone else, not at the character herself.

In my eyes, Pinkie is a spoiled child who's never learned that you can't always get what you want.

I'm sorry, I'm no good at arguing, but I really want people to understand

edited 27th Mar '12 8:24:55 AM by gingerninja666

Headline: Applejack and Rarity go on 'special camping trips.'

Headline: Rainbow Dash goes missing. Police suspect Pinkie Pie.

edited 27th Mar '12 8:25:42 AM by PurpleDalek

Cheerilee is dating Big Macintosh *fingers crossed*

Twilight plays with toys in the bath

Rarity dyes her hair

Applejack eating a pear.

Applejack cosplaying as Terry Pratchett.

I agree with this.

Whenever I can honestly feel like Pinkie is being treated like a real character rather then a blunt instrument of humor, she still usually comes across like this.

I'm pretty sure everypony knows that by now.

edited 27th Mar '12 8:28:40 AM by Mio

Applejack talks to her apple trees in the middle of the night

Rainbow Dash discovers rocketry

@Dalek: Well, they went scouting the perimeter together in It's About Time, and Rarity is seen picking leaves outta AJ's mane as they come back to report.

Sooooo, did they find any new positions?

So I came upon a moment of brilliance today. I can objectively prove that MLP:Fi M is a good show (not that we already didn't know it).

First, we define what makes a "good" show: All television shows seek to entertain. The more people it entertains, or the amount of entertainment it provides, the "better" the show is.

MLP:Fi M entertains lots of people and provides a good deal of entertainment, therefore it is a good show.

Ta-da!

ARGUE WITH ME!

edited 27th Mar '12 8:29:32 AM by wazkatango

Remember Rarity wiping AJ's face in the same episode... who wrote that one, again? It was a mediocre episode, but it sounds like we've got a secret shipper on board the write staff. =)

@Waz: ...Nope, got nothin' you're absolutely right there coolface.jpg

@Red: Soooo true

Oh man, potholing for emphasis is awesome.

edited 27th Mar '12 8:31:11 AM by AceOfScarabs

OBJECTION!

You failed to quantify the amount of entertainment produced by the show, and failed to provide a threshold for calling it "good".

>:( louisangryface.jpg

Ok. Ask any of the viewers how much they enjoyed the show (if you want, from 1 to 10). Add.

edited 27th Mar '12 8:32:06 AM by wazkatango

and it makes sense that Twi would put them together in that ep given the events of LBYS.

Rare notices all the little details while AJ keeps them both focused on the task at hand.

... not sure if that's still an innuendo.

Not really. The X Factor entertains millions of people. Doesn't mean it's a good show. Or good for humanity in general.

@Kyler: It amused me enough to learn the memes, therefore it is good.

@Ginger: as I wrote on the Les Yay page, perhaps there was more than a Friendship Lesson being learnt ;D

edited 27th Mar '12 8:32:43 AM by AceOfScarabs

OBJECTION!

Kyler is nitpicking the witness.

@Purple: No, actually it is by my definition. So I don't like the show. So what. It still does a great job at being a good TV show.

I mean, this is what hipsterism is all about. "Hey, I liked this show when it only had 3 viewers. And it's a better show than that namby-pamby popular show over there."

edited 27th Mar '12 8:34:43 AM by wazkatango

OBJECTION!

You failed to provide supporting arguments, and so your conclusion has no basis.

@Waz:

1. That argument can be used to prove that the likes of Jersey Shore, Twilight, and Justin Bieber are also objectively good.

2. Seriously, do I even need to explain why this is a problem?

3. Q.E.D.

edited 27th Mar '12 8:35:00 AM by JapaneseTeeth

I think a lot of the problem here is that there have only been four episodes that have focused on anything remotely resembling Pinkie's personal desires: Party of One, Griffon the Brush Off, Baby Cakes, and A Friend in Deed. Griffon the Brush Off is the odd one out because Pinkie actually fails in it. Gilda does not become a better person, and doesn't become her friend. With that in mind, I think she could use more focus episodes, not less like some people seem to want. Our sample pool is too small right now to determine such character traits as "she never learns anything" or "she always gets what she wants" (even though I just gave an example where she doesn't).

@JT: Unfortunately, they are. I know, it's a weird thought, but it checks out. Just because Justin Beiber is a bad singer doesn't mean he's a bad entertainer. See where I'm getting at here?

edited 27th Mar '12 8:37:14 AM by wazkatango

OBJECTION OVERRULED

Storyyeller is awesome. (Also, Redd White is totally blackmailing the judge)