'Night, Applelight. Dream of Pinkie Pie.

Most of the Twist disapproval comes from her overload of adorkable, as though she was trying too hard.

edited 16th Feb '12 7:26:49 PM by AceOfScarabs

Alright, now to rank some side characters using that same system. (this one, if you missed it)

Apple Bloom:

Character: 7/10

Cuteness: 9/10

Humor: 6/10

Awesomeness: 4/10

Total: 25/40

---

Sweetie Belle:

Character: 8/10

Cuteness: 7/10

Humor: 7/10

Awesomeness: 5/10

Total: 27/40

---

Scootaloo:

Character: 5/10

Cuteness: 7/10

Humor: 6/10

Awesomeness: 9/10

Total: 27/40

---

Spike:

Character: 7/10

Cuteness: 3/10

Humor: 9/10

Awesomeness: 7/10

Total: 26/40

---

Bonus Round!

Derpy Hooves:

Character: 3/10

Cuteness: 8/10

Humor: 8/10

Awesomeness: 6/10

Total: 25/40

And... Side characters fall right in with the mane 6 in rankings... Yeah, I really can't rank anything, can I?

edited 16th Feb '12 7:27:54 PM by PerpetualLurker

damn you poeple and you uber posting while I'm raiding.

@ Lurker: Sweetie Belle only gets a 7/10 for cuteness? But... but... The Face Scoot...

Seraphem: Lurk less post more

The board's slowing down to a sane level now.

Tara Strong is best pony

edited 16th Feb '12 7:32:17 PM by dmysta3000

There's no character I really hate in this show, only that some stand out more to me than others. (Although I do make in exception for Diamond Tiara, I hates the bitch. But I also understand that she was basically made to me the little spoiled rich girl stereotype, still don't like her.) That is why I have a hard time ranking these characters because 99.8% of them have compelling pros and cons. This is unique to this show for me.

edited 16th Feb '12 7:33:40 PM by Allik

Twilight....... No, you like humans, damn you!

@Allik, I hear that sentiment a lot, the "I don't really dislike anypony". I'm a total rebel yo, I dislike TWO ponies! Beat that y'all!

I I ever talk like that again, I want you all to shoot me.

edited 16th Feb '12 7:34:14 PM by MousaThe14

@Syd: The only characters scoring higher the Sweetie on cute are Fluttershy, Derpy, and Apple Bloom. Remember that Cuteness is relative. By default, all ponies are very cute, so you have to be extra cute to rank high. Making 7/10 is quite the feat.

@Allik, Mousa: Yeah, my recent experiment here pretty much proved that I don't like any one pony too much more than another.

edited 16th Feb '12 7:36:22 PM by PerpetualLurker

Bluh, too many people hate DT and SS.

But I didn't say Silver spoon for a reason.

EDIT: Wow, no one posted before my response this time

edited 16th Feb '12 7:37:20 PM by Allik

I find them obnoxious, but I don't hate them.

@ Syd I said raiding, not reading.

I like Silver Spoon

Oh, I ranked the ponies too.

Applejack: 34
Twilight: 33
RD: 31
Fluttershy: 28
Rarity: 23
Pinkie: 16

Diamond Tiara is badly in need of charisma breaking :V

@Mousa Just Mousa, or the other aspects of you as well?

edited 16th Feb '12 7:41:17 PM by crowlover

I like Silver Spoon

Me too. I think she can still be redeemed if she'd ditch the bitch.

I think Silver Spoon is gonna get better and grow out of DT shadow so I am hesitant to look down on her right now. I hope DT is humbled in time, but this will take a real break the cutie/haughty moment for her.

@Syd I still think there's hope for DT. If there was ever a place for hope, it's this show

Oh, there's easily hope for DT. I've known lots of people who were asses in elementary school but mellowed out as they matured. My headcanon is that Apple Bloom and DT are bros when they get older. Yes, bros. Because I can't think of a good female equivalent.

@ Ginger: At least DT's dad disapproves of her behavior and wants to straighten her out. We don't know what her mom's like, though.

Diamond Tiara can be redeemed for sure!. but she has a long road a head...

@Crowlover, Rainbow Dash appeals to AC, but then one idiot deserves another. But he also he and Pinkie are best friends, traverse the fourth wall and everything together.

Jazz L may not hate Rarity like I do but he doesn't love her either, but he has a higher degree of respect for her than I do.

Which sadly leaves the resident a-hole; M The Geek is where most of my love for Twilight Sparkle is harbored, creepy git.