When Pinkie was revealed as the (first) Mare Do Well, I could have sworn I could hear the distant sound of a Welsh tea drinker's blood boiling. Glad I was mistaken.

I have no idea.

And it better be something creative.

I mean, her defining character trait is apples.

What is this.

@Syd No, seriously, I had NONE, not a SINGLE issue with Pinkie in this episode

... Do I hear horsemen?

edited 26th Nov '11 3:10:09 PM by gingerninja666

I wonder if the fact that Rainbow Dash kept wasting time by doing her introduction speech was meant to be a deconstruction of or a Take That at the whole idea of superheroes entering by introducing themselves rather than simply jumping into action.

About Pinkie Sense, since it mostly seems to predict falling objects, I wonder if it's something she inherited from her rock farm family or developed as a defense mechanism against things like avalanches (which could possibly be a common occurrence when one is doing "rock farming"). Granted, in "Pinkie Keen" she predicted other things (like "alligator in the bathtub") but most of the predictions do seem to involve falling objects. Or maybe another term for it would be a general "danger warning" sense. Or else she's simply psychic but can't quite control when she has premonitions.

edited 26th Nov '11 3:11:18 PM by Rainbow

There's worse character traits. If I wanted to be friends with anypony it would be Applejack if only for a discount on apples.

edited 26th Nov '11 3:10:07 PM by Badwolfwho

It's three A M and I am still watching MLP nonstop, for I have found a fast enough source to download.

I wonder if I am weird.

However, I could have guessed that I am. What kinda person would read Ask Princess Molestia and think "Yup. This is right up my alley. I wanna watch what those people are watching."

My point is that those aren't character traits at all.

edited 26th Nov '11 3:15:19 PM by thefran

I dunno, I'm the one who watched the show because of Flutterguy.

Probably a byproduct of all of her gypsy magic clearly.

Did the same thing back in, when was it May? I dunno.

Not because of Molestia though, because of Rainbow Dash and Pocahontus.

edited 26th Nov '11 3:15:31 PM by Badwolfwho

I think I hear trumpets.

There are weirder reasons people have gotten into this show.

edited 26th Nov '11 3:15:17 PM by Mio

I'm pretty sure the Mayor was on the thing. She accepted Mare Do Well a bit too quickly...

Pony platformer game is pretty cute. I suck at it though.

@Mousa: Well, it looks like it was enough to save her parents, so why wouldn't it predict the future, I guess?

Eeyup. If I were to pick a pony to hang out with, it would be Applejack.

Twilight? Too brainy. I'd feel dumb with her.
Rainbow Dash? Too much of a jerk.
Pinkie Pie? I'd never be able to keep up with her.
Fluttershy? I'd scare her too much.
Rarity? Too high-maintenance.

The mayor knew who was mare do well all along

I like to imagine that. I like it when the mayor can actually be usefull

she's one of my favourite characters after all

The whole town was in on it

Nah, probably not, but with the amount of coincidence in the episode it almost seems like it.

She's one of my favorite characters, as well. Now, if only they'd give her a proper name.

I SO want her to get her own episode (she won't, but I can still wish)

I just call her Mayor Mare

Wait, why did the mayor name the Mare after a term used to describe a CRIMINAL?!

Perhaps the Mayor likes puns and irony?

@Kegisak: But now that's she's gone beyond saving her parents it's clear she'll never stop. The fourth wall has been baked into a brew and now she's everywhere! when will it end!?

In retrospect, it would have been faster to just download s2 again on my laptop, instead of trying to transfer files from desktop :|

If we go with the "Mayor Was In On It" theory, then did the Mayor come up with the name on the spot? Or did the mane cast TELL her what they wanted to be called?

Now I've got this mental image of the cast huddled around a table discussing superhero names.

edited 26th Nov '11 4:00:01 PM by gingerninja666

The costume had an M on it. Logically the Mayor was either in on it and hence knew the name or saw the M and made up a name beginning with M.

"Superpinkie" just doesn't fill me with fear, for some reason.

Twilight: We need something inspiring that will show we mean well but not willing to reveal ourselves

Pinkie Pie: How about Captain PARTY!

'Rarity: I think that's a little too obvious, darling.

Fluttershy: Maybe the masked defender?

Pinkie Pie: ooh oooh! I know! Super Dark Cloaky Hat Mare! The Dark Surprise! The MASKED AVENGER! Spoil Rainbow Dash Mare! Spoiler for short!

Fluttershy:Um, excuse me...

Rarity: Honestly, can't you come up with anything simple but stylish at once?

'Twilight: I'm trying to concentrate, I can't with you yelling like that, Pinkie!

Fluttershy:Excuse me...

'Pinkie Pie: Maybe we can name her Party hardy Har har! or Cloaky! Big hat! Purple Mare!

Rarity: Huw about something more glamorous for once? Maybe the Shining Knight? The Mare of Mystery?

Fluttershy: Excuse Me! I mean.. sorry. Um, Maybe... The Mysterious Mare Do Well....?

edited 26th Nov '11 4:08:29 PM by MousaThe14