@ JT Probably a Rainbow Dash one. I hadn't really decided yet. Just knew I wanted one.

Edit: Oh, you probably meant it the other way. There's some mugs that are black until you put hot water inside them then they reveal a picture underneath. Somebody made some with ponies.

edited 25th Oct '11 1:27:48 PM by CDRW

That would be fucking hilariously cute.

Maybe in an ep, her and pinkie have to eat their way out of some place. Pinkie's ok, but 'Buttershy' is so bloated and fattened she can't fly or walk, and has to be rolled to move!

^Pinkie's metabolism is ridiculously high, after all.

And what, it's a lesson on fitness or eating in moderation?

cough. Thanks to... the internet. I've already seen at least two versions of Buttershy.

I can't show here, but yes, it is REALLY cute

Even then, I'd say that Pinkie is slightly chubbier than the rest of the cast

edited 25th Oct '11 1:37:43 PM by gingerninja666

I'm curious but you said that you can't show it here so I'm not sure how curious I should be.

Saw it. Funny as hell.

Also, Buttershy belching would be hilarious, because she's usually so quiet and polite:

UUUUUURRRPPP!

excuse me

Followed by her trademark little squeaky noise.

edited 25th Oct '11 1:38:01 PM by ApplelightLimited

^^It's okay for you not to be curious.

^^^Exactly; Pinkie has a crazy metabolism, and she still eats enough to be a little pudgy. =D

edited 25th Oct '11 1:39:07 PM by RedSavant

Pinkie must be a bit on the plump side.

Not massively fat or anything, just, plump and chubby.

Pinkie is the anti-Maromi

I wouldn't even say she's overweight, just... heavier than the other girls.

Who's the thinnest?

edited 25th Oct '11 1:42:54 PM by gingerninja666

Pinkie plump

Thinnist would be difficult to identify. On the one hand it could be Rainbow dash from all her cardio.

It could be Rarity because she seems like the type to not only obsess over her weight but try to look like a fashion model, or it could be Fluttershy because she seems like the type.

i think I went Fluttershy because I also made her the tallest("I'm a year older than you.")

edited 25th Oct '11 1:44:57 PM by MousaThe14

I'd say it would be between the two pegasi.

Rarity could be thin yeah. But something tells me she would also be curvey as hell. All the better to show off those dresses!

edited 25th Oct '11 1:48:46 PM by ApplelightLimited

Agreed. Rainbow Dash is the most active besides Pinkie and Applejack (Applejack probably wouldn't be "thin" per se because of muscle development), and Fluttershy probably doesn't eat very much.

Applejack is the one I would furthest remove from the thin side, too much farm work and kicking trees. If there were more body types I imagine she'd look like a short Big Mac.

To me, AJ would be pretty buff. But still feminine.

edited 25th Oct '11 1:48:28 PM by ApplelightLimited

I'd say Fluttershy would be too curvy (maybe moreso than Rarity)

^I imagine it's Dash. Applejack and Dash are our athletes, after all, and Dash is the one who's focused on speed and aerodynamicity rather than strength, so she probably has less muscle mass than Applejack. What she has is definitely very strong, though - toned like steel cable. =D

a little late for this but I'd like a second opinion on something about "Lesson Zero".

based on Celestia's dialog, she was going to punish Twilight and only didn't because the rest of the Mane Six made her realize that they all leaned something from the ordeal. am I off base on that? because when I think about it, there had to have been some consequences for Twilight fir her massive misuse of magic if the others didn't show up.

In my mind, and in human terms:

Dash looks just like a 18-21 year old Jennifer Nicole Lee (if she was a Latina with rainbow hair): [1]

And AJ looks like a blonde, ponytailed, befreckled, 18-21 year old version of that that woman who played Natasha the sniper in Red Alert 3: [2]

edited 25th Oct '11 2:00:15 PM by ApplelightLimited

^^Celestia was probably going to talk to Twilight about her misuse of magic, but not punish her - given that Twilight had already punished herself more than enough, with her OCD freakout and later, with her depression. Celestia's "I'm listening" makes it rather clear that she's encouraging the girls to work out their own friendship report together; she wants them to think about it. Her objective is to make sure that Twilight and the girls learn about friendship, not to scare them or punish them.

^Re: the first picture: Her breasts are way too big for Dash. Those don't look aerodynamic at all. And yes, I realize I'm biased, but I really don't understand the whole 'Latina Dash' thing, either. Can't we have a sporty girl who isn't The Vasquez?

edited 25th Oct '11 2:02:23 PM by RedSavant

One funny thing about the Nicole Oliver podcast (which I can't find) is when she said that she would banish her kids to the moon. Now I'm imagining Celestia with mischievous sons.

I don't think Celestia planned on punishing Twilight at all, she just wanted to give her a stern talking to. Twilight had to get her lecturing abilities from somepony after all.

Oh yeah.

Ok, imagine her 18-21, rainbow hair, and much smaller chested.

She is tanned though. That's something RD would be.

edited 25th Oct '11 2:03:24 PM by ApplelightLimited

Tanned blue!