Rarity dislikes such vulgar celebrations.

I wonder how many of those costumes were designed by Rarity, and what she thinks of them. Does she like doing crazy designs for Nightmare Night, or is she disdainful of them?

I'm going to guess that Derpy designed her own costume.

edited 22nd Oct '11 12:21:57 PM by Crowfall

QUICK! MAKE A PINKIE VS LUNA "FOREVER" VID!

Lauren Faust was right when she said Luna's return would be epic. I'm glad she didn't show up before this now.

Help! I started watching and now I can't stop thinking about ponies! @_@

An elephant standing on a car? Was Pinkie Pie involved somehow? True.

edited 22nd Oct '11 12:47:35 PM by ChocolateCotton

Better not think of an elephant standing on top of a car, then.

There's worse things to be obsessed about, really.

Rarity lock herself just like F Lutershy, but for another reason, she could not stand all those amateur costume desings

Well that was a pretty decent episode.

I was rather pleasantly surprised by the way they went with Luna's personality (though I guess now I'll have to endure fan fic authors having her speak entirely in capslock).

I'm still kind of scratching my head at how Twilight seemed to be the only one who recognized Princess Luna for who she was. I mean it's not like she wasn't introduced to the whole town that one time by her big sister.

Rarity was in it and interacted with Luna but that part was cut out.

Faust elaborates on what Rarity's part in the original script was.◊

edited 22nd Oct '11 12:51:48 PM by Kerrah

Of all the worst things that could happen, this is THE. WORST. POSSIBLE. THING!

JOIN THE SOLAR SISTERHOOD.

IM. HO. TEP.

IM. HO. TEP.

Having seen that storyboard drawing of Derpy appearing in this episode, I was kind of hoping she'd say something.

I'm still waiting for that...

I kind of prefer that she doesn't have any lines. That way, we get to keep wondering whether she really does talk funny or not.

I'm kinda dreading that. Since so far they seem to be playing up how ditzy she is, I'm afraid that they're gonna give her a... Derpy voice.

edited 22nd Oct '11 1:07:51 PM by gingerninja666

It would be really funny if they made her eloquent. Crazy eccentric, but eloquent.

Huh? "Kathleen Barr is Princess Celestia?" But...we know that it's Nicole Oliver—she's listed as Princess Celestia in the credits and she confirmed it in that interview. Did Lauren Faust mistype, or what?

I liked the voice when derpy said "muffins."

OMG this was so worth the wait!

There's not much about cannon Luna that I can say that others already have said, but Jebus H. Webster I loved her!

I loved everyone who appeared. Even Pinkie Pie. She was just getting into the spirit of things, and probably didn't realise that she was hurting Luna's feelings.

And I knew Pip would have an important role to play!

WE ARE A HAP-PEE BRON-EEEE!!!

Hmm...

edited 22nd Oct '11 1:14:34 PM by Kerrah

@whatshisgame: I am confutated.

WE HAVE JUST WATCHED THIS EPISODE ON YOUTUBE BECAUSE OUR MOTHER WOULDN'T LEAVETH US BE OTHERWISE. WE LIKE THIS EPISODE. QUITE SO. HAMMY LUNA IS BEST LUNA.

WHAT WE DO NOT LIKE IS ALL OF YOU TROPERS TAKETH SUCH SADISTIC JOY IN INSULTING FAN FIC WRITERS.

WE LOVE FEASTING ON THE RAGE-INDUCED TEARS OF FANDUMB AS MUCH AS ANYPONY ELSE, BUT THERE BE-ETH A FINE LINE BETWEEN "WE KNOWETH NEXT TO NOTHING ABOUT PRINCESS LUNA'S PERSONALITY OTHER THAN THAT SHE DOTH FEEL REMORSE FOR HER ACTIONS, SO LET'S TRYETH TO MAKETH SOMETHING HEARTWARMING FROM IT" AND    "HOW DARETH HASBRO DEFILE THE PERSONALITY OF MY SHY MOE WAIFU!!!!!!1!11!!ONE!1!!!1ELEVEN!!!11!!!1"    SAYING THAT YOU REVEL IN THE SMELL OF A THOUSAND FANFICS BURNING DOTH MAKE THYESELVES LOOK LIKE TOTAL DOUCHEBAGS. VERILY, WHAT HAST HAPPENED TO "LOVE AND TOLERANCE?!"

PRECISELY! DUE TO THE COMPLEXITY OF OUR FAVORITE FICTIONAL EQUINES' CHARACTER TRAITS, COMBINED WITH THE SHEER LACK OF CONCRETE CANON BEFORE THIS EPISODE, THERE ARE STILL PLENTY OF THINGS FANON COULD BE RIGHT ABOUT. UNTIL LUNA SHOWS UP AGAIN, WE WILL NOT KNOWETH FOR CERTAIN.

WHAT IF WE WERE TO SLAP THY EXCREMENT?

edited 22nd Oct '11 1:20:23 PM by takashi.0

I'd have loved that!

I'm not satisfied with this episode at all (but if I'd voice that the mob'd lynch me). But teaching the most frightening mare about the fun of being frightened (and Halloween) would have made a lot better plot, I think.

There are so many cartoons about the meaning of Christmas, one about Halloween would've been awesome and original.

I think that's not spam, but barely -_-