My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Forum Archive (nuked Yack Fest thread)
Page 55 | Posts 1351 - 1375
#1351ParableSat, 26th Mar '11 11:28:34 PMfrom California
Today I learned there was a reason so many people liked to use a picture of Twilight with the words "Spoiler" written at the bottom on Ponychan.
I'm so dumb.
Heh. I like that fact that Pinkie's contains a hallucinogen. That seems appropriate.
Faust says that they're all in their late teens - around 17 or 18. Personally, though, for all of them living on their own, and Twilight being a college student, I'd say they're closer to their early 20's/ Fluttershy actually seems the most autanamous, so I'd call her the oldest, maybe around 21 or 22? Applejack and Rarity both seem as mature as her, running their own businesses, so They're probably about the same age. Pinkie Pie we know is a year younger, so call her 20...I'm not sure who to call youngest, Dash or Twilight. Dash is a drop-out, so could easily be in her late teens, starting work early, and has the personality for it, but she was also made the leader of the weather team, so she's obviously respected...'d call her 19, maybe? Twilight is still in her studies, but was clearly a good ways in to them, so I'm thinking she's maybe 19 or 20 herself.
#1367Kyler ThatchSun, 27th Mar '11 10:12:11 PMfrom Gravity Falls
Given how unrelated maturity and physical age can be, it's really very hard to tell.
I mean, going by that metric, would you have guessed that Fluttershy was only one year older than Pinkie Pie?
I took a guess and cut a portion out of my heart.
He said, "That's nowhere close enough, but it's a damn good start."
#1368ParableSun, 27th Mar '11 10:14:06 PMfrom California
That's a good point, but I was thinking maturity more in terms of their duties, not how they act. Mature or not, you wouldn't give someone young control of a whole farm (Though I think she's only partially responsible for it, what with Big Mac), and Rarity owns a fairly sizable store/house combo, meaning that she would have had to worked pretty well before starting it, unless her parents are fairly wealthy. I suppose, though, thinking like that the only real source of comparison is between Fluttershy and Pinkie Pie.
#1370Ori DoodleSun, 27th Mar '11 10:35:25 PMfrom Home Sweet Home
I think Twilight is more of a grad student, and that Fluttershy acts younger than her actual "age".
TS: 24
F Shy: 22, acts 20 because of shyness
Applejack:22
Dash: 20—dropped out at 17, spent two years in pony-ville on the weather team proving her worth
Rarity: 23
Pinkie: 19-20
Spike is 14 or 15. Rarity is his very first crush.
I can't wait for the back story episode! I want to know if Dash is originally from Cloud city.
Forum Herald for the Old Folk's Home
Team Mom
Restrain yourselves. You are not the first person to feel.
#1371GelzoSun, 27th Mar '11 11:43:45 PMfrom the vault
They aren't human, or even from our realm of reality, so there's no reason to expect years to correlate to mental and/or physical maturity the way they do for us.
For instance, our horses reach full maturity in five years, and on average only live until their late 20s.