Sweet and Elite is pretty much my favorite episode overall.
I didn't really mind Rarity in Sonic Rainboom. She was too ridiculous for me to really get bothered.

Really? I didn't think they were that off in PYHD. *

Then again, I don't see many problems with that episode in general.

*

It takes me far too long to realize what episode people are talking about if they use acronyms. It took me forever to realize what "SRB" and "GIYC" were.

Sweet and Elite is possibly my least favourite Series 2 episode.

I really liked Putting Your Hoof Down.

Who are you and what have you done with the human who's place you took?

PYHD was one of those cases where I didn't really see any problems when I watched it, but then later when I thought about it I noticed a few odd things. But that kind of thing only bugs me if I notice it during the episode, though. If I don't realize the problems until well after the fact, I'll totally go with it because it means the episode was good enough to keep me distracted.

My main complaints about PYHD were actually that the bugs bunny thing seems like a Dead Horse Trope, and the prices given make no sense. I didn't mind the characterization.

edited 2nd Jun '12 11:23:13 AM by storyyeller

Yeah PYHD, it wasn't really ONE thing that was completly OOC, but just so many little nearly OOC things added up to make the whole thing feel off....same (just a BIT lesser degree) as MMDW...and both are by the same writer so.

And yet he also did Hearthswarming Eve....which was amazing, though that COULD be because it was really about 6 OC's not any established characters so there WAS no OO Cness.

That seemed like a clunky sentence. You must be a alien who's taken the place of a human and doesn't know how to construct a succinct sentence.

I still don't see the major problems everyone complains about.

edited 2nd Jun '12 11:25:22 AM by Badwolfwho

*shrug*

I still don't think that PYHD was all that bad. They weren't nice, but I don't think they were OOC either.

Anyway, I have to get going again, so hopefully I'll pop in again in the next day or so. See you guys later.

Rainbow Dash is damn good with kids.

Also to the one that one links to.

I had no problem with Rarity (who I liked) or anything else in PYHD.

Sweet and Elite is...good, but not as good as certain other Rarity episodes. Suited for Success, followed by Green isn't your Colour are still my favourites there.

Rarity is my second least favourite of the Mane 6, but that's just because I started liking the other members of the Mane 6 before Rarity. She's great, but I still prefer a lot of other ponies.

It probably has to do with the fact that I would avoid Rarity IRL (then again, the same applies to Rainbow Dash, but at least Rainbow Dash would be fun to watch IRL).

Hey again

How has everyone been? I've just been reading

I am and always will be a Rarity fan.

Hello, Ginger.

edited 2nd Jun '12 11:38:57 AM by PurpleDalek

Hey, Ginger. We're talking about Rarity and PYHD.

Ah yes, Rarity. The hipster pony of choice

I still wouldn't call her episodes my favourites.

Though Rarity HAS risen to be my 4th favourite pony now

I loved Rarity before it was cool!

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9P-0x-kX0D4&feature=related

Watch it.

Rarity's nowhere near my fourth favourite pony. My fourth favourite pony is Luna. (My third favourite is Photo Finish).

Fffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff-air enough

and I meant 4th favourite out of the mane cast

edited 2nd Jun '12 11:45:34 AM by gingerninja666

FUCK! I'm off my feet for FOUR FUCKING MINUTES and my sis is badgering me to watch things with her. -_-

fucking HELL!

Who fell?

What stuff?

edited 2nd Jun '12 11:48:53 AM by Badwolfwho

Damn you Marston I go on a wiki-walk from that youtube video and end up here.

edited 2nd Jun '12 11:49:20 AM by CDRW

@bad what?

I know that feel man. I have both a sister AND a friend who keep begging me to watch stuff with them. And guess what? One of the things they wanted me to watch was a Harry Potter movie.-_-

edited 2nd Jun '12 11:50:01 AM by marston