My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Forum Archive (nuked Western Animation thread)
Page 4688 | Posts 117176 - 117200
Calnos avatar
#117176 from Nowhere
I don't think its out of the blue for Twilight to have a brother. Spike is for all intents and purposes like a littler brother to her.
Black Hat Productions
Sydxelia avatar
#117177
My reaction to the "Twilight has a brother" rumor:

edited 6th Mar '12 5:18:20 PM by Sydxelia

Pronounced "Sid-zellia"

Fools! You've overestimated me!
Drenius avatar
#117178 from Northern Virginia
I'll stick to my notion that for some reason SA is estranged from the rest of his family and the invitation to come to the wedding is his attempt to mend fences and establish a relationship with his little sister. Of course this all hinges on the rumor being true.

[up]Probably the best attitude to have at the current point

edited 6th Mar '12 5:20:56 PM by Drenius

Gully Foyle is my name, and Terra is my nation. Deep space is my dwelling place, and death's my destination.
Allik avatar
#117179 from Oh you know where
I have to agree with Crowfall that it is possible that the two were born years a part and so weren't in a lot of contact if any with each other.
"But who prays for Satan? Who...has prayed for the one sinner who needs it most?" - Mark Twain
Japanese Teeth avatar
#117180 from Meinong's jungle
Celestia's school isn't necessarily a boarding school, but it wouldn't surprise me at all if it was.

And yeah, the fact that Twilight has a brother isn't that weird, I just wouldn't have expected it to be SA. Maybe she just doesn't see him often because he's in the army or something.
( ◕‿‿◕ ) Reaction Image Repository ( ◕‿‿◕ )
Bagof Magic Food avatar
#117181
I like the idea that Shining Armor is a knight (despite my being bothered by prescient names), because I can imagine Twilight wanting to follow his example, and that's why she's always been so ready to go on dangerous missions in the name of Celestia.
dmysta 3000 avatar
#117182 from New York and New Jersey
So lets see, the son is a decorated Knight, and the daughter is the personal student to a God Princess.

How rich are the Sparkle family?!
"YOU'LL ALL HAVE CHINS!!!"
Japanese Teeth avatar
#117183 from Meinong's jungle
They wouldn't necessarily need to be rich; Twilight got into the school because Celestia noticed Twilight at her entrance exam. SA could have easily started at a bottom rung and worked his way up.
( ◕‿‿◕ ) Reaction Image Repository ( ◕‿‿◕ )
Applelight Limited avatar
#117184 from Manehattan to Canterlot
Age gaps can make quite a differance...my mother is the youngest in her family at 45...her oldest sister is 69!

But anyway, wait...if Twlight is...Twilight Sparkle...and he's Shining Armour...how do pony family names work!

edited 6th Mar '12 5:26:35 PM by ApplelightLimited

Tealove is best pony. Pony Fanon Workshop
Rainbow avatar
#117185
The idea of Twilight having a brother is interesting, although hopefully it will answer the question as to why she's never mentioned him before, not even to Celestia. I may delay my next-gen fic even further just in case this would have any impact on Twilight's future and by extension, her children. If I did start it sooner it might end up being at least mildly AU (as many fics for an ongoing series end up being anyway).

I don't mind Twilight having a long-lost sibling, but I'd still wonder why she never would have mentioned him. Hopefully if he does turn out to be her brother they will answer that question.

edited 6th Mar '12 5:26:47 PM by Rainbow

Pink Sugar Heart Attack!
crowlover avatar
#117186
  • flies in*

IS the Sparkle family. Family is singular!

  • flies away*
MLP Thread Poster Movesets
Crowfall avatar
#117187
So Twilight is not only the personal protege of the princess, but is also the soon to by sister in law to another princess who may or may not be related to Celestia, and no one at Jet Set's party recognized her?
MLP Thread Poster Movesets
Allik avatar
#117188 from Oh you know where
I just hope this won't be or somehow lead to a Tenchi Muyo! style family tree where all the main characters are conveniently related to each other. Damn just pissed me off, too much Mind Screw and squick mixed together.

[up]&[up][up]Refuge in Audacity much guys? evil grin

edited 6th Mar '12 5:29:15 PM by Allik

"But who prays for Satan? Who...has prayed for the one sinner who needs it most?" - Mark Twain
Calnos avatar
#117189 from Nowhere
Being rich would certainly explain where Twilight got that balloon. It twinkles for Celestia's sake!
Black Hat Productions
nomuru2d avatar
#117190 from Inkster, MI
... BZZT. RRRG. BWBWBWBWBWBWBW. BLAAAAAAAAAAAAA-*the mind you have dialed is no longer in service*
If you wish to know, you only need to ask.
Sydxelia avatar
#117191
@ Applelight: My aunt had four kids, waited about 15 years, then had two more.

edited 6th Mar '12 5:28:53 PM by Sydxelia

Pronounced "Sid-zellia"

Fools! You've overestimated me!
Sydxelia avatar
#117192
Being rich would certainly explain where Twilight got that balloon. It twinkles for Celestia's sake!

I'd say it sparkles more than twinkles.
Pronounced "Sid-zellia"

Fools! You've overestimated me!
Red Savant avatar
#117193 from Eastern US
I definitely liked the idea someone (keg?) floated a while ago - that Cadence is basically Equestria's spymistress, and in order to keep herself safe and able to move around relatively covertly, she plays the pretty pink princess schtick for all it's worth, while in actuality she's a fairly cool (or fairly chill) person, and nowhere near as saccharine or as brainless as she pretends to be. She's fond of Shining Armor, but may or may not actually love him.

Shining Armor, on the other hand, is just bursting with good intentions, but he's actually the rawest of raw recruits. He's a good person, but his major qualification is that he looks like a knight, and thus he's perfect for Cadence's purposes. He may or may not know who she really is, but either way he's dedicated to her.
Can you think inside the chimney?
Seraphem avatar
#117194 from Delamare
holy shit yeah, Linkara just did a pony shout-out in his latest video

edited 6th Mar '12 5:30:45 PM by Seraphem

Build a fool proof system, and the world will create a better fool.
Flapjackmaka avatar
#117195 from Pennsylvania
Just saw the season finale synopsis. Wow. New material for shippers
The candle that burns twice as bright burns twice as fast.
storyyeller avatar
#117196 from Appleloosa
She got it at the toy store of course!
If there is anything that you are alone in thinking, it's "thinking that you're alone in thinking of your theories".
Mousa The 14 avatar
#117197 from Northern Virginia
I thought the balloon was the town rental.

But I guess it would make sense if she was rich, being Celestia's prestigious student from a fancy pants city like Canterlot.

Blue hair like the pops, pale white-ish coat like the ma, cutie mark with the same star as Twilight. Similar night sky theme as the rest of the family in terms of Cutie marks, and well whaddaya know, I think he has his mother's eyes.

.... Is it just me or is his horn huge?
I analyze "Geek Culture" here.

When All Else Fails, worry, that's the 14 way.
Whatshisgame avatar
#117198
No, it really twinkles

edited 6th Mar '12 5:32:39 PM by Whatshisgame

Crowfall avatar
#117199
Twilight's family being rich would explain how she can afford to just hang out in a library all year studying friendship. Makes as much sense as Celestia giving her a research grant.
MLP Thread Poster Movesets
dmysta 3000 avatar
#117200 from New York and New Jersey
It would kinda make sense if Twilight was a Lonely Rich Kid at the start of the show...
"YOU'LL ALL HAVE CHINS!!!"