@ J teeth, ok it had to happen, for once I REALLY disagree with a lot of stuff in your review.
Your issues with the
Cold Open not really having a big relevance other then humor- And the issue is...? this isn't some heavy drama, there is no reason for there NOT to be a few scenes here and there that exist solely to make the viewer laugh, as long as they don't end up being
Manatee Gag's
You issue with the song making Pinkie seem universally loved-I've covered this one with you before, it was a musical number, you have to take the images with a grain of salt, it's not like anyone really thought Pinkie could clone herself because she had two of her in song, and even assuming there were a large number of ponies actually singing, like I said, ponies just HAVE to join into big musical numbers no matter what, but really, the second the song was over, there was NO where near as many ponies in sight.
And the whole second half where you claim she ignored her epiphany in the library-No she didn't, she accepted that Cranky would never want to be her friend, but she still felt horrible about destroying his book, the second chase was not about being friends, all she wanted was to apologize and make up for what she now knew she had screwed up. true she never does understand WHY Cranky doesn't like her, but that's another issue. Slight differnce, but it does matter.
Finally, she DID learn the lesson, she realized Cranky needed his space, and respected that...at least cerebrally, she's still hardwired to go all out and forget stuff like personal pace when she gets excited, but she took the hint very quickly once the donkeys reminded her, she just left. If they keep the contiuity with this, it would mean that yeah, she'l still do everything to make friends she can, but she'll also be willing to take the hint that the new pony just needs some space. Or that some friends just need time alone, it doesn't mean they hate you just becuase they don't want to be around you 24/7
Build a fool proof system, and the world will create a better fool.