Differnce is the Find a Pet didn't loop, this one just repeated the same verse over and over, and yes it was good, but probably could have cut a bit off.

Ponyhemian Rhapsody page topper

edited 28th Jan '12 7:47:46 AM by Seraphem

It seemed longer than that because they sang INCREDIBLY FAST!

As i said, my main problem with the song is just its too long. Make it a little shorter, and it would've been fine.

Really didn't like the Flim Flam brothers though. I kept trying to shoot them with my NES Zapper.

Ahahahahaha

So this is the fifth M.A Larson episode of the season? Well it does explain Pinkie at the beginning.

I’m going to start off with THAT SONG. That song was just great. I was expecting the brothers to have a song, but not a full blown number like that. It was a pleasant surprise. Also, Granny Smith singing? What is this? I saw a background pony during the song that had a brown coat and a wrench cutie mark. She looked nice.

I think this was the first episode I pretty much saw coming the whole time, aside from the other mane six helping.

Pinkie’s bed mane is adorable, and she really does have parties for everything, doesn’t she? Rainbow just can’t catch a break, and it is hilarious. She’s still her typical self, but not getting what she wants is just so perfect.
The Flim Flam Brothers really don’t like that fence. What did it ever do to them? The rest of this is just random thoughts I had during the contest.
Twilight, that is the best plan. I honestly didn’t see the teamwork coming; I thought the Apple Family would just win on their own. Fluttershy, how are you so good at knocking the apples down like that? It doesn’t seem like something she would be good at…

The Flim Flam brothers are kind of…bad at this. Tree Cider? Sounds delicious.
Bon Bon continues to have hilarious voices.

And I’m going to continue to chime into the “best lesson ever” crowd.
I'm going to have to place this really high on my list, but I can't tell if I like it more than The Last Roundup or not.
And the writer was M.A. Larson, to the person who asked.

I actually agree with Ginger about Pinkie for once. When the cider is selling out every day leaving a huge line of disappointed ponies, buying a dozen cups is a little dickish. I actually wanted to see RD call her out on it.

i loved it too...but i don't consider it a villain song.

Art of the dress was much longer than this song you know

Yeah so well..LOVED RD IN THIS ONE.

When I saw the hospital in the episode after this one, I thought for a second that we were going straight into Read it and Weep.

Why not, Moe? I thought they were fun for how sort of obviously slimy they were.

edited 28th Jan '12 7:50:03 AM by kegisak

Animation Error

Error my ass, I loled up a storm.

If anything, Flim and Flam obviously seemed to care about each other.

I love loving sibling villains

@Ace: That's not an animation error, she just hit the cider a bit too hard.

M.A. Larson is writer for this ep?

Hmm I think it is his "worst" ep with Sonic Rainboom. But my top episode list is Larson Tier so even his weaker episode are preatty strong.

But I need to watch again to form opinion.

Animation error or drunk Cheerilee? You decide!

MA Larson clearly doesn't like Dashie much D:

Cheerilee is clearly related to Berry Punch

We should expand upon that. Character building.

edited 28th Jan '12 7:55:40 AM by Chariot

I liked the song. Considering that I rarely like this show's songs, that is "loved" by comparison.

@Crowfall: That is interesting observation. Usually when there is high demand and limited amounts a lot of companies set limits on how much you can order. Oh well. Doesn't make as compelling a conflict anyway.

@ Robbie, again It's not the length in and off itself, it's that all it did was repeat itself over and over.

As to Flutter-harvest all she has to do is fly into a tree, and then think of something scary till she starts shaking so hard all the apples fall down.

So good episode then?

Applejack said that cider sales keep them afloat in the winter. If they're no longer sole cider providers, they would have to give up the farm anyway.

was berry punch in this? i was waiting for her to show up...