the depribooru crowd tends to not like giant descriptions like that. It reminds them of cartuneslover.

Thanks for the comments guys.

@Seraphem: As a stand along it's pretty bad and I wouldn't hesitate to remove, but since that is not possible I think it works to think of it as part of RD's overall character arc. Also, I've always been rather confused by how people seem to think that RD was at her "worst" at that point in the series when I always felt she was less likable in season one.

@ed: That is true, I think it would should have emphasized that more in that part. It also sort of comes up in Games Ponies Play too, though there is a lot of projection of her own desires going on in that episode too.

A person who mis known for crossover art of questionable quality

edited 1st Jun '13 10:18:45 AM by Mio

@ ed

Thanks. Good point on RD too.

Oh. Who's that?

edited 1st Jun '13 10:15:53 AM by ApplelightLimited

Someone who drew some pretty dire cartoon crossovers.

I'm not sure if the description was really the problem. I've had pictures where I had no idea what people were negatively reacting to.

Well I'm trying to learn about Type Thoery on Wikipedia.

Can you pull pics from there, or will I just have to take it.

cartuneslover is an artist who does a lot of nonsensical crossover art with Regular Show, Chowder, and other cartoons. sometimes crossover shipping is involved.

her images usually always have huge descriptions.

you can request to have a mod delete it, but I'd just leave it.

edited 1st Jun '13 10:24:19 AM by Blissey1

Just to give a small idea of how bad Cartuneslover's crossovers are: You know the awful and nonsensical "Twilight/Mordecai" pairing? She's partially responsible for the pairing's popularity, and unlike most people she plays it compleatly straight and full of OOC-ness with both charectors instead of doing it for lulz.

I don't know, but some of my stats posts were really, really long.

Incidently, I discovered that page 14469 wasn't the only one affected. 14668 and 14670 have fewer posts than expected as well.

I saw the ones with characters from Fish Hooks, but I was never brave enough to click any of them. Were those here?

edited 1st Jun '13 10:28:50 AM by edvedd

I'm not sure there is a character limit. I've written posts that took up a good two or three pages in a word processing doc. That's about 2, 000 words.

I can't look...well, I had my first dud. Ah well, bound to happen.

Well I think I have the longest post in the thread. I was going to check how long it was, but ran into the lost page problem from a while back so I had to modify my parser yet again.

Looked at a few of that person's pictures, and I'm honestly not sure where all the downvotes are coming from. Is it because I TL;DR the descriptions? How can anyone get enough of a sense from these pictures to declare OOC?

Interesting. By my count, the longest post in the thread was not a stats post, but a number. It's 37811 characters long. Of course my length count doesn't include markup or certain tags such as quoteblocks, but I'm pretty sure that's still the longest post in the thread.

14469 was a whole in space-time when for a brief moment, the reality-warping scoothulhu invaded this reality.

It was only through the efforts of Twilight Sparkle's spells cast from the Equinomicon that allowed the abomination to be resealed.

And that was all you.

edited 1st Jun '13 10:39:48 AM by edvedd

New◊ official◊ magazine◊ story◊!

But it wasn't just one page. It also affected parts of the two adjacent pages, interestingly enough.

I just wish I could get a comment...even one saying why they hate it.

@ Apple: It could be the lack of a mane/tail, but who knows, really? Don't worry about it.

He's not shaded either.

Yup, this reminds me of my AJ human pic. I had no idea why that was being downvoted all to hell because no one was saying anything. That's the worst-case scenario, really. You know people dislike it but you don't know why.

edited 1st Jun '13 10:46:45 AM by edvedd

@Applelight: I'm guessing it's the overly long description combined with the lack of detail on the drawing itself. That and the lack of any sort of hair makes him a bit weird-looking. Maybe give him a buzz cut or something rather than making him completely bald.

@Mio: I mostly agree with you on RD. I've never considered MMDW that bad though. I've actually rewatchd it severaltimes and enjoyed it everytime (and yes, I've deliberately gone, "I feel like watching MMDW").

@Whatshis: Have to check that out. Those can actually be fascinating. They gave us Anticipatory Paralysis!