My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic Forum Archive (nuked Western Animation thread)
Page 14313 | Posts 357801 - 357825
Rhyme Beat avatar
#357801 from Eastern Standard
Does anyone else find it really awkward that ponies and zebras have cutie marks but horses don't? Ponies are a breed of horses and far more distantly related to zebras... But the lattter has marks and the former doesn't?
Off Beat Ofense
Eagal avatar
#357802
Yes please. Would a camel in a fez be too much though?

Voiced by Matt Smith. ;)
Praise to Itempas, Dayfather, Brightlord
kegisak avatar
#357803
[up][up]My fanon on that note is that those two are the 'gods' of Saddle Arabia, and have simply forgone cutie marks, possibly for cultural reasons. Or on that line, perhaps they've been covered for cultural reasons.

It's also kinda questionable whether or not Zecora actually has a cutie mark proper.

edited 16th Apr '13 1:42:45 PM by kegisak

Sereg avatar
#357804 from South Africa
Does anyone else find it really awkward that ponies and zebras have cutie marks but horses◊ don't? Ponies are a breed of horses and far more distantly related to zebras... But the lattter has marks and the former doesn't?

Admittedly, I did find that weird. Maybe the common ancestor had cutie marks and they were lost in horses and donkeys?

EDIT:@Kegi: The horse gods aren't any bigger than Celestia? Also, it's unusual for the gods to be the dellegates. I assumed that the horses' rulers would be about three times Celestias size.

edited 16th Apr '13 1:44:59 PM by Sereg

Unity of the Sun Mare
Japanese Teeth avatar
#357805 from Meinong's jungle
@Rhyme: These ponies are multicolored and have magic. It's so far away from real biology that it's best not to think too hard about it.
Reaction Image Repository/Tumblr
Rhyme Beat avatar
#357806 from Eastern Standard
Maybe it's an animation error as the cloth thing could have been meant to conceal a cutie mark but it was misplaced. Is that at all likely?

Off Beat Ofense
Applelight Limited avatar
#357807 from Manehattan to Canterlot
Thanks guys.

Those pony eating plants btw. Think badass ponies would hunt them?
Tealove is best pony. Ask The Mane Six
Sereg avatar
#357808 from South Africa
It's so far away from real biology that it's best not to think too hard about it

But trying to understand the biology of fiction is something I love to do! It comes from me studying to be a biologist.

EDIT:[up]As much as they'd do any other monster slaying, which admittedly is less than humans would based on how pony culture seems to work.

edited 16th Apr '13 1:49:22 PM by Sereg

Unity of the Sun Mare
Rhyme Beat avatar
#357809 from Eastern Standard
It's not even for the sake of realism like the donkey design. The mare is pink with a purple mane for crying out loud.
Off Beat Ofense
kegisak avatar
#357810
@Sereg: No, because their not horse gods, but pony gods. Hence why they're the same size and build as her, roughly speaking. Saddle Arabia in my fanon is an offshoot of El'bia, an earth-pony only country. After the 'death' of their first god, Amos of the shifting sands(Not to mention the related political issues), the country underwent a small schism and a small faction seceded and declared itself independent, taking on a couple 'ambitious' small-time old souls as their patrons. Part of Celestia making base with them was to keep the politics of the region stable(As Equestria was already a trading partner with El'bia), and partly to fully integrate the new gods into the cosmic council... and keep an eye on them. They're the youngest gods after Celestia and Luna, so they seemed to be the most likely to keep them calm, as opposed to say the roughly-50-thousand year old Ciel of the Sky and her extended family, or the moderately younger but rather imposing duo from their neighboring country, Ferghus of Iron and Simon of Stone.
Applelight Limited avatar
#357811 from Manehattan to Canterlot
@ Sereg

Since the ponies could eat them, it could be a form of hunting.
Tealove is best pony. Ask The Mane Six
Santos L Halper avatar
#357812
wild mass guess The two emissaries are Spice Manna addicts. Sufficient consumption of Manna enables non-Unicorns to practice magic, but at the cost of their special talent, basically making them Jacks of All Trades. wild mass guess

edited 16th Apr '13 2:04:03 PM by SantosLHalper

Posey avatar
#357813 from Colorado, USA
[up]

Please let that be canon. grin
Sereg avatar
#357814 from South Africa
@Kegi: Ah. Cool. But they seem to have diferent snouts from the ponies. Also:

They're the youngest gods after Celestia and Luna

Um... Aren't you forgetting a certain pink princess? (Interesting that you see Celestia and Luna as right at the bottom though. I consider them reasonably high up, but not near the top).

@Applelight: Hmm. I guess so. All right.
Unity of the Sun Mare
Japanese Teeth avatar
#357815 from Meinong's jungle
This had better not turn into another power level discussion. tongue
Reaction Image Repository/Tumblr
Irish Zombie avatar
#357816 from Texas
And llamas, so they can do a Shout Out to The Emperor's New Groove.

a pony bumps into Celestia while she's dancing

Celestia: "Dude, you threw off my groove!"

Guard: "Sorry, but you threw off the Princess's groove."

pony gets thrown off the mountain

Or even better:

Twi and Pinkie go down to the lab below the library

Twilight: "Pull the lever, Pinkie!"

Pinkie pulls lever, Twi falls down trap hole

Twilight: "WRONG LEVEEEEEEEEEEeeeeeeee-" splash

edited 16th Apr '13 2:22:46 PM by IrishZombie

Oh, no! They've all transformed into giant, Swedish, lederhosen-clad yodelers! Run!
storyyeller avatar
#357817 from Appleloosa
Any obscure food that crosses cultural lines tends to become bizarre.

Like peanut butter.
Life is simple: it has no nontrivial normal subgroups.
kegisak avatar
#357818
@Sereg: Oh. Hm. Umm...

wild mass guessCadence may be a goddess, she isn't technically a part of the cosmic council yet. She'll be officially included at the same time as the Saddle Arabian Delegates. For the moment they're just letting her ease into the Crystal kingdom, and they'll see if it recovers enough to become a new country, and therefore she'd be deemed a Regal Old Soul and made a part of the council, or if it remains a city-state, In which case previously she would have been moved to take control of El'bia as it's new leader, though there's a fraction of the council that desires to respect Amos's last wishes and not have a new council member take the throne, and Celestia would push for Twilight to take over after a while to keep Cadence from having to relocate, since the Crystal Ponies view her as a hero.wild mass guess

So she doesn't 'count' because she's not in control of a country and therefore still on the same level as basic old souls - who are not necessarily lesser than the council. The strongest Old Soul in existence generally wants nothing to do with the council, and the feeling is mostly mutual.

(Also, considering Luna and Celestia as the youngest doesn't necessarily make them the bottom, but they're far from the top - it was a narrative device used to demonstrate that there are ranks on the totem pole much higher and more dangerous than them.)

edited 16th Apr '13 2:34:50 PM by kegisak

Japanese Teeth avatar
#357819 from Meinong's jungle
@Irish: "Why do we even have that lever?"
Reaction Image Repository/Tumblr
storyyeller avatar
#357820 from Appleloosa
Those pony eating plants btw. Think badass ponies would hunt them?

Ponies eat plants all the time. Not sure why they'd be hunted though.
Life is simple: it has no nontrivial normal subgroups.
Applelight Limited avatar
#357821 from Manehattan to Canterlot
@ story

These plants can move, and are hostile and dangerous.
Tealove is best pony. Ask The Mane Six
Japanese Teeth avatar
#357822 from Meinong's jungle
@Story: The comic has carnivorous plants. You've got to wonder whether the ponies would eat them. It certainly raises the interesting question of whether they grill up plant steaks or something.
Reaction Image Repository/Tumblr
Applelight Limited avatar
#357823 from Manehattan to Canterlot
@ JT

Veggie sausages? Are they a thing?

Any vegans in here?
Tealove is best pony. Ask The Mane Six
Turtlebutter avatar
#357824 from A Marshy Pond
I drew an Ass while waiting on hold for a Doctor's office.
Pony Cinema - The Best Little Pony Video Site on the Internet
Pony Forum
storyyeller avatar
#357825 from Appleloosa
The comic has carnivorous plants. You've got to wonder whether the ponies would eat them. It certainly raises the interesting question of whether they grill up plant steaks or something.

I know, I just got a little confused by Applelight's Ambiguous Grammar and decided to joke about it.
Life is simple: it has no nontrivial normal subgroups.