MLP Forum Archive - Page 12650

#316226 d Roy Thu, 13th Dec '12 11:49:49 AM from Buffalo, New York

Top 10...well, let's see if I even can come up with ten.

Ponyville Confidential
Mystery Express
Over a Barrel - I mostly liked it because I wasn't taking it seriously. In fact, there is not a single episode I actually took seriously, really.
Sisterhooves Social.
Hearts and Hooves - Hell yeah, Juggernaut Mac.

Yeah...these are the only episodes I actually like.

edited 13th Dec '12 11:54:00 AM by dRoy

No heroes, no villains, only people.

#316227 Purple Dalek Thu, 13th Dec '12 11:50:57 AM from Betelgeuse

@Sereg I'm very sorry to hear that.

Yeah, this is just a case of different perspectives. I'm a reasonably confident person so HF just didn't do much for me.

"A toilet with the potentially dangerous arrangement of the seat being up" - Wikipedia

#316228 Sereg Thu, 13th Dec '12 11:54:52 AM from South Africa

Editted my own lis in.

@Purple Dalek: Thanks. Yeah. As I said, HF left me in tears.

Unity of the Sun Mare

#316229 Mio Thu, 13th Dec '12 12:01:07 PM

Well, I think I would need more time to really come up with a concrete list, but going with what I have posted before and how I feel about the current episodes I think I can go with this for now. . .

1. Sisterhooves Social

2. Sonic Rainboom

3. Hurricane Fluttershy

4. Too Many Pinkie Pies

5. Winter Wrap-Up

6. Sweet and Elite

7. Secret of My Excess

8. A Dog and Pony Show

9. Suited for Success

10. Sleepless in Ponyville

edited 13th Dec '12 12:01:27 PM by Mio

Pony Fanon Workshop Semi-Regular Attendant

#316230 latenight Thu, 13th Dec '12 12:05:52 PM from moonburnt

I found the episodes entertaining with varying degrees. Most I'd watch again and there are one or two that I just can't bring myself to. None have made me angry because then I would stop watching the show.

Here's my top 10 in no particular order except the first three

. Its also because I can't remember the episodes that well. A rewatch is in order.

A Canterlot Wedding - Part 2
Sonic Rainboom
Winter Wrap Up
Suited for Success
Party of One
Luna Eclipsed
Hearts and Hooves Day
Sisterhooves Social
A Dog and Pony Show
Green Isn't Your Colour

edited 13th Dec '12 12:06:49 PM by latenight

#316231 Purple Dalek Thu, 13th Dec '12 12:13:10 PM from Betelgeuse

I'll just do a top five:

5) Return to Harmony (Discord. That is all.)

4) Magic Duel (Yay! Trixie! And Yoda-Zecora!)

3) A Dog and Pony Show (Best Rarity episode? Best Rarity episode.)

2) Dragonshy (Best Fluttershy episode? Best Fluttershy episode.)

1) Sisterhooves Social (I actually teared up just a little bit when Rarity found Sweetie's painting.)

"A toilet with the potentially dangerous arrangement of the seat being up" - Wikipedia

#316232 storyyeller Thu, 13th Dec '12 12:16:26 PM from Appleloosa

I'd have a lot of trouble deciding on just ten, or on ranking them.

Life is simple: it has no nontrivial normal subgroups.

#316233 kegisak Thu, 13th Dec '12 12:17:53 PM

I'd say my list in an approximate, but not exact top ten are:

Baby Cakes
Green Isn't yur Colour
A Dog and a Pony Show
Hurrican Fluttershy(I do know what it's like to be bullied so I'm sympathetric, but most of my enjoymnt comes from the colour and energy of the episode)
Sleepless in Ponyville
MM Mystery
Luna Eclipsed
Hearth's Warming eve
Cutie Pox(Or Sisterhooves Social, they're kinda tied)
It's about time

All tend to be visually vibrant, character-heavy ordeals. But then, that usually describes the show as a whole...

#316234 storyyeller Thu, 13th Dec '12 12:21:10 PM from Appleloosa

I generally rate episodes by how funny I found them.

Life is simple: it has no nontrivial normal subgroups.

#316235 Rainbow Thu, 13th Dec '12 12:23:51 PM

My top ten, in no particular order, aside from the one I listed first:

1. Sisterhooves Social
2. Best Night Ever
3. Baby Cakes
4. The Discord 2 parter (I count it as one episode since it's all one story)
5. Suited for Success
6. Lesson Zero
7. Applebuck Season
8. One Bad Seed
9. Hearts And Hooves Day
10. MM Mystery on the Friendship Express

Pink Sugar Heart Attack!

#316236 Bluespade Thu, 13th Dec '12 12:33:16 PM from Fort Worth, Texas

@D Roy: I'm really not trying to be rude or tell you to get out of our fandom or anything... but if you only like five episodes out of 50+ episodes don't you think you might be wasting your time watching the show? There's a whole bunch of other shows out there to watch.

Since we're doing these lists I guess I'll add mine:

1. Canterlot Wedding.

2. Luna Eclipsed.

3. Hearth's Warming Eve.

4. Magic Duel.

5. A Dog and a Pony Show.

Fight. Struggle. Endure. Suffer. LIVE.

#316237 Cookoo Thu, 13th Dec '12 12:42:55 PM from A Cuckoo clock

Honestly, I can't say I dislike any of the episodes. I just enjoy them. Way more fun than disliking things. ^_^

This does mean I have serious trouble ranking the episodes.

My Pony Fantasy 6 liveblog. ^_^

#316238 crowlover Thu, 13th Dec '12 12:43:53 PM from Name & Address Withheld

And I am still unable to rank my favorite episodes...

#316239 Bluespade Thu, 13th Dec '12 12:45:39 PM from Fort Worth, Texas

Watching episode 7... WITHOUT SPOILING ANYTHING the start of this episode has some major shipping fuel.

Fight. Struggle. Endure. Suffer. LIVE.

#316240 storyyeller Thu, 13th Dec '12 12:50:16 PM from Appleloosa

Hopefully not bunker fuel. The CO 2 emmissions on that stuff is atrocious.

Life is simple: it has no nontrivial normal subgroups.

#316241 Bluespade Thu, 13th Dec '12 12:54:22 PM from Fort Worth, Texas

Okay, more like this entire episode is shipping fuel. For multiple ships.

Fight. Struggle. Endure. Suffer. LIVE.

#316242 Irish Zombie Thu, 13th Dec '12 12:54:36 PM from Texas

Nah, he just means the Equestrian airships. Apparently, those things run on rainbow juice.

No, not that kind of rainbow juice.

edited 13th Dec '12 12:57:47 PM by IrishZombie

Hate them veggies...

#316243 Purple Dalek Thu, 13th Dec '12 12:55:42 PM from Betelgeuse

Isn't that kind of unsanitary? And I'm sure it would be uncomfortable for Rainbow Dash.

"A toilet with the potentially dangerous arrangement of the seat being up" - Wikipedia

#316244 Bluespade Thu, 13th Dec '12 12:58:36 PM from Fort Worth, Texas

Okay I'm only halfway through but I think I might need to revise my favorite episodes list.

Fight. Struggle. Endure. Suffer. LIVE.

#316245 crowlover Thu, 13th Dec '12 12:59:13 PM from Name & Address Withheld

@Blue And now I am tempted to create a list of every shippy moment I notice when watching.

#316246 Japanese Teeth Thu, 13th Dec '12 1:01:45 PM from Meinong's jungle

@Blue: The ending is also shipping fuel. You'll know the moment.

And I should totally say that my top ten is pretty malleable. I mean, I really think that some episodes (say, Magic Duel) are good enough to be up there, but at the same time I don't want to remove any episodes from it.

Reaction Image Repository/Tumblr

#316247 Bluespade Thu, 13th Dec '12 1:01:55 PM from Fort Worth, Texas

Seriously, there are so many. Including background pony ships.

BLUH my bro came home for lunch. Now I'll have to postpone watching the rest of this episode.

edited 13th Dec '12 1:05:04 PM by Bluespade

Fight. Struggle. Endure. Suffer. LIVE.

#316248 d Roy Thu, 13th Dec '12 1:05:53 PM from Buffalo, New York

I'm really not trying to be rude or tell you to get out of our fandom or anything... but if you only like five episodes out of 50+ episodes don't you think you might be wasting your time watching the show? There's a whole bunch of other shows out there to watch.

I understand where you are coming from. I should make it clear, that even the episodes I Really Disliked have some amusing moments. It's just that when I am done watching I started to hate it even more. All the episodes have some cute and funny moments, so that's more than enough for me.

Besides, for me only 0.001 percent of the fun being part of this fandom (don't ever call me a brony) is from the actual episodes.

edited 13th Dec '12 1:06:09 PM by dRoy

No heroes, no villains, only people.

#316249 Bluespade Thu, 13th Dec '12 1:07:56 PM from Fort Worth, Texas

Shrug. To each their own.

Fight. Struggle. Endure. Suffer. LIVE.

#316250 Calnos Thu, 13th Dec '12 1:07:59 PM from Nowhere

Background ponies own ships, now? What would Derpy's ship be like? Would Time Turner's ship be Bigger on the Inside? Would Lyra serve nothing but hay smoothies aboard her ship?

You there! Check out my Youtube Channel! The power of Ponies compel you!